Long Island South Shore and Lynbrook

HISTORY WEBSITE

E-mail: Lynhistory@AOL.com                      Web Address: Lynhistory.com                          Phone: (516) 887-7673

Presented by Lynbrook Historical Books, 28 Hart Street - Lynbrook, NY 11563-1711

Copyright Protected © 2005-2010 by Arthur Mattson and Lynbrook Historical Books. All rights reserved.


Mr. Mattson is the 2010 recipient of the Joseph F. Meany Award for excellence in New York State Maritime History.

The prize was awarded by the Association of Public Historians of New York State.

        Front Cover and Spine - eStarkfinal - 12 Aug 2009 - 01                        Sold Out.jpg

              1st Edition Published, 2009                                                      2nd Edition Published 2010  

          $24.95                                                                                      $29.95

Hardcover copies are available from Amazon Books; downloadable, digital copies from Amazon’s Kindle Books.

To obtain an AUTOGRAPHED COPY of either book direct from the publisher, click on one of the book covers above. The link has an order form and provides additional information from the back covers and inside flaps.

Both books are gorgeous, oversized, coffee-table type books. They will make fine gifts for anyone interested in New York and Long Island history, or in sailing.

 

Topics in Water and Ice

U.S. Maritime History – Shipwrecks – Irish immigration in the 1830s – Tall ships in the Age of Sail –Death of 215 Passengers and Crew – Walt Whitman’s shipwreck-poetry – Currier and Ives prints of the wrecks – The New York Harbor Pilots – Land Pirates – The Origin of the U.S. Coast Guard’s Sea-Rescue Mission – Lighthouses:  Montauk Light, Fire Island Light, Ambrose Lightship, Sandy Hook Light, and Navesink Light – Places:  Baldwin, Dublin, Far Rockaway, Freeport, Hempstead, Liverpool, Lynbrook, Long Beach, Near Rockaway, New York Harbor, New York City, Rockaway Beach, South Street Seaport – Genealogy:  Lists of Passengers, Crews, and Rescuers.

Summary of Water and Ice

A tall, marble monument in the Mariners Burying Ground in Lynbrook's Rockville Cemetery recalls two horrific, long-forgotten tragedies on the South Shore of Long Island. Worn engravings on this 170-year-old obelisk reveal that this is the final resting place of 139 victims of two shipwrecks in the winter storms of 1836-7. One hundred passengers and crew on the tall ship Bristol drowned when a massive wave filled her hold with water, just 400 yards off Rockaway Beach. A few weeks later, 115 crewmembers and passengers— most of them women and children from Ireland—were forced to go up on the deck of the barque Mexico, just 200 yards off Long Beach, in a blizzard. When their captain and crew abandoned them, they all froze to death, their bodies encased in coats of ice. Mr. Mattson’s research into this long-lost story took him to historical archives in Dublin, Liverpool, St. Croix, and across the U.S.

This true story from the 1830s is a sadly universal one of the cruel treatment of immigrants by those who transport them for profit. Today, for example, we have “coyotes” leaving immigrants to die in the deserts of the Southwest, and greedy boat captains dumping people outside New York Harbor or in the sea off Haiti.  In the 1830s, immigrants were treated as less valuable than the cargo in the ships’ holds. Water and Ice is a story of Long Island, New York City, Ireland, and England—of heroic rescuers, artists, and poets—and of cowards, body robbers, and greedy shipowners.

The wrecks were the biggest news story of the day in the U.S.  Walt Whitman wrote about the wrecks in Leaves of Grass, Currier and Ives created prints, and the Supreme Court issued an important decision. Today the story is all but forgotten.

In 2008, Mr. Mattson presented a paper discussing the two wrecks at the Conference on New York State History at Skidmore College. That paper (sans images) may be accessed by clicking on the following:

NYS Conference Paper

 

Praise for Water and Ice

Water & Ice is the engrossing story of two shipwrecks off Long Island, which were major catastrophes in 1836-37. Arthur Mattson’s extensive research is reflected in the great detail he presents about the two ships: their voyages, the devastating events in which they were lost, and the subsequent heroic rescue efforts. Water & Ice is a significant addition to maritime history and to New York and Long Island history as well.

—Natalie A. Naylor

Professor Emerita

Hofstra University

 

 

 

The scholarship and passion that went into this book overwhelmed me, even as the drama kept me sailing through to the end. This is a book that deserves a wide audience.  It's a surefire, exciting read, as well as a textbook of a sort in that it contains a wealth of information.  I'm a landlubber but I got an education on tall ships with his guidance.

Murray Bromberg

Author

 


 

Lynbrook Historical tidbits:

 


Mural in the Lynbrook Post Office - by Kevin O'Malley.

(Looking north up Atlantic Avenue, from where LIRR trestle is today)

                       

Frank Short "Shorty The Cop" (ca. 1930) and Lynbrook's Five Corners (ca. 1940), looking east down Merrick Road.

A “Brief History of Lynbrook” by Art Mattson

appears at the end of this web-page.

__________________________________________________

Art's CORNER

(Letters from visitors to this site)

For historical Information about the Village of Lynbrook, New York, established in 1785, incorporated in 1911, and formerly known as Pearsalls, Pearsall's Corners and Bloomfield,

click on one of the following topics:


How Lynbrook Got Its Name

(From Rechquaakie to Near Rockaway to Parson's Corners to Bloomfield to Pearsall's Corners to Pearsall's to Pearsalls, and finally in 1894 to Lynbrook)


The Rockaway Indians ONE MILLENNIUM AGO

How the Rechquaakie of East Rockaway, Lynbrook and Lakeview Lived


Whittaker Chambers' Home in Lynbrook

A paper covering Whittaker Chambers' years in Lynbrook, his home for 42 of his 60 years. Discusses the influences Lynbrook had on his life.


The History and Ownership of 71 Union Avenue      

Lynbrook's most historic house, home to a Civil War hero and many of Lynbrook's leading families, recently demolished.


The Lynbrook Bottling Company

Read about Lynbrook's victim of the "Great Depression"


Lynbrook's Historical Markers - Texts and Locations

·         LYNBROOK - ESTABLISHED 1785

·         LYNBROOK'S FIVE CORNERS

·         THE SAND HOLE CHURCH

·         THE MARINERS BURYING GROUND


The Wreck of the Sailing Ship Bristol - November 21, 1836

Read two contemporaneous newspaper accounts of the wreck of the sailing ship Bristol on the sandbar off Long Beach.  The Rockville (Sand Hole) Cemetery in Lynbrook has an obelisk marking the common grave of 139 Irish, Scottish and English immigrants who drowned in the winter storms of 1836-37.  Many of the victims were women and children.

Favorite Links:

“Immigrant dreams founder off Long Island”  (Irish-American History blog of TheWildGeese.com)

Historical Society of East Rockaway and Lynbrook

Malverne Historical

13th Independent Battery - NY Light Artillery - David Driscoll's Civil War Unit

Records of the Rockville Cemetery (Old Sand Hole Cemetery) and records of Various Lynbrook families (Abrams, Davison, Pearsall, etc.)

 

E-Mail:

lynhistory@aol.com

Available by E-Mail request:  An 1888 (scanned) map of Lynbrook, with locations shown for property owners: Abrams, Allen, Bedell, Box, Brower, Burtis, Cornell, Cowper, Davidson, DeMott, Doxey , Dredger, Ehredorf, Furman, Graef, Hughes, Hutchinson, Jones, Kuen, Langdon, Lee, Leach, Mott, Pearsalls, Plinkington, Rider, Seeley, Shaw, Simonson, Smith, Van Deusen, Watts, Wood, Wricht (Wright).

 

The book, The History of Lynbrook, is a beautiful, 240-page, coffee-table-sized hardcover book with about 170 images and illustrations.

 

Click Here to Order The History of Lynbrook

 


A Brief History of Lynbrook

By Art Mattson

Copyright Protected © 2009

Permission to republish is required.

 

Source:  The History of Lynbrook, (pub. 2005) by Arthur S. Mattson.

 

            For hundreds of years before English and Dutch settlers arrived, the Rockaway Indians, an Algonquin group, lived in the area we today know as Lynbrook.  They called the place Rechqua-Akie, “a sandy place.”  When the Europeans arrived in 1641, they re-named the place Near Rockaway, from a mispronunciation of the Indian name and because of its nearness to Hempstead, which was the main settlement.   By 1785, there were 40 houses in the area, and in 1790 a Methodist church was constructed at Ocean Avenue and Merrick Road.  The settlement became known as Parson’s Corners.  Small farms gradually spread westward toward the Five Corners – at the intersection of Hempstead Ave., Merrick Rd., Broadway and Atlantic Ave – and the area around the Five Corners became known as Bloomfield.

 

Around 1830-40, a young businessman from East Rockaway, Wright Pearsall, opened a general store and post office at the Five Corners.  His store prospered so much so that, by 1850 he and his family owned almost all the land around the Five Corners.  The name Pearsall’s Corners took hold.   In 1853, the Merrick Road was planked with hemlock boards and made into a toll road, providing a choice of ways to get from Lynbrook to New York City:  by stagecoach-and-ferry or by packet boat from East Rockaway.

 

            When the Southern Railroad extended its line through Pearsall’s Corners in 1867, it brought big changes.  For starters, the railroad shortened the name of the hamlet to Pearsalls.   Other changes were more profound.  Previously, the village had an economy based primarily on shipping non-perishable goods such as milled wheat and corn to New York City and to more distant ports.  But now the railroad enabled Lynbrook to pack and ship fresh farm produce and seafood direct to downtown Brooklyn and then on to New York City in just a few hours – for cash.  For example, in the month of February, 1882 alone, 356,350 pounds of oysters were shipped from the Pearsalls railroad station. This new flow of commerce was not just one-way. Dry-goods-stores, restaurants and inns were opened in Pearsalls.  By 1890, the hamlet had grown to over 2,000 residents, many of them daily commuters to jobs in downtown Brooklyn.

 

            On April 4, 1894 a group of newcomers to Pearsalls pushed through a name change – to Lynbrook, which is “Brooklyn” with syllables transposed. The name was changed over the strenuous objections of many old-time residents.  They continued to call the hamlet “Pearsalls” for another 25 years.  Along with the new name, the newcomers brought about many improvements such as gas mains, electricity, and telephone lines.

 

            The year 1911 formally marked the end of Lynbrook as a country hamlet.  That is the year the Village of Lynbrook was incorporated.  Within the next twenty years, bonds were issued to pave dirt roads with concrete, build a Municipal Building, and construct an all-brick High School and a neo-classical-style Library.  By 1925, all the remaining farms had been subdivided into business and housing lots.  That year Lynbrook was named the fastest growing village in Nassau County. 

 

            In recent years, a new library, village hall, recreation center and community pool have been constructed.  The downtown business center has been revived with the help of a federal grant. For the past 20 years, with little land available for development, Lynbrook’s population has hovered around 19,500 to 20,000.

 

 

Lynbrook’s Most Famous People:

Henri Charpentier ran Henri’s French Restaurant, on Scranton Avenue. Opened in 1906, the restaurant became world famous.  It was patronized by presidents and generals, and gastronomes from as far away as Europe.  The invention of the crepe suzette is credited to Henri Charpentier.

 
Henri

 

 

Lynbrook was home to Whittaker Chambers, the communist spy, writer, and witness for the prosecution in US vs. Alger Hiss.  Chambers grew up in a house on Earle Avenue, beginning in 1904 when he was three. He lived in the house off and on throughout his life.  Chambers wrote an emotional chapter about his life in Lynbrook in his influential book, WITNESS.

 

 
     chambers

 

Wright Pearsall -- Wright Pearsall was the founder of Lynbrook.  His general store, post office and stagecoach stop was the most important business in town in the mid 1800s.  The name “Pearsall’s Corners” took hold, lasting for 50 years until the name Lynbrook was adopted in 1894.

 

 

Most Important Events in Lynbrook’s History: 

A Revolutionary War Battle was fought at Lynbrook’s eastern border.  On June 22, 1776, George Washington’s militiamen marched east along the Merikoke Indian trail (Merrick Road), to Near Rockaway.  They came to the home of a British Loyalists, Isaac Denton, near the intersection of Merrick Road and Ocean Avenue. But he, along with many of the Loyalists that they were looking for, fled into a nearby swamp at today's Tanglewood Preserve. Nineteenth-Century historian Henry Onderdonk Jr., in his book, Revolutionary Incidents of Queens County, tells the story:

 

The party of Washington’s soldiers went to Hempstead swamp (at the head of Michael DeMott's mill pond) to take up some Tories who were hiding there. The Tories made some resistance, and fired on the soldiers in the woods. The soldiers returned the fire, and wounded George, son of William Smith. The Tories then called for quarter. The soldiers took six prisoners and put them in Jamaica jail. [http://www.lihistory.com/4/hs402a.htm]

 

The Rockville Cemetery on Lynbrook’s eastern border has a memorial to the tragic loss of over 200 Irish, Scottish, Welsh and English immigrants who drowned in the winter storms of 1836-7 in wrecks off Long Island’s South Shore.  139 of the unfortunate passengers of the ships Bristol and Mexico are buried there in a mass grave.  This was one of the worst sea disasters in American history.  The story is the subject of Art Mattson’s soon-to-be-published book, Water & Ice.

 

 

Lynbrook's Mayors and Presidents

From 1911 to 1927 Lynbrook had ‘Presidents’ elected for 1-year terms. From 1928 on, ‘Mayors’ were elected for 4-year terms.

#

Year Elected

 or Filled Unexpired Term of Predecessor

Name

1

1911, 1912

August D. Kelsey

2

1913

Milton F. Abrams

3

1914, 1915

George F. Adair

4

1916

James H. Dayton

5

1917, 1918 & 1920

George W. Wright

6

1919

Charles H. Lott

7

1921

Percy Howard

8

1922, 1924

Phillip Stauderman

9

1925. 1926

George E. Winter

10

1927, 1928, 1932

Howard G. Wilson

11

1936, 1940, 1944

William K. Ross

12

1948, 1952, 1956 (died in office 1958)

Fred A. Greis

13

1958, 1960, 1964

George H. Mangravite

14

1968, 1972, 1976, 1980 (resigned 1981)

Francis X. Becker

15

1981

Glenn Spielman

16

1983, 1987

William Geier

17

1991

Mary Colway

18

1995, 1999, 2003

Eugene E. Scarpato

19

2007

Brian Curran

 

Lynbrook Village Facts:

 

Lynbrook’s Official Mottos: “The Village That Leads the Way” and “Een Draght Mackt Maght  The latter is Dutch for: “In Unity there is Strength,” which is also Brooklyn’s motto.  Remember:  “Lyn-brook” is “Brook-lyn” with syllables transposed.

 

Lynbrook’s Official Song:  Lynbrook, USA” - Words and music by Paul E. Holm.

 

Lynbrook’s Seal: designed by Jay Stroly in 1986.

 

Lynbrook’s Village Hall:  dedicated in 1970

 

Lynbrook’s Highest Elevation above Sea Level:  31 feet (at Hawthorne St)

 

Lynbrook’s Total Area: 2.0 square miles

 

Lynbrook’s Population: 19,669 - as of Jan 1, 2000

Source is LIPA [http://www.lipower.org/community/index.html#Pop.%20Survey]

 

 

 

Passenger Lists of the Bristol and the Mexico

Wrecked on the South Shore of Long Island, New York in 1836-37

(From the new book, WATER AND ICE, see the top of this webpage)

 

The 111 Passengers Aboard the Mexico

All froze to death, except three men, as shown.

Sources:

Liverpool Customs House Records

Printed in the New York Sun, January 12, 1837.

Supplemental data from New York American January 5, 1837.

 

Names

Age

Occupation

Country

Thomas Anderton

36

Farmer

Unknown

Ellen Anderton

30

None

Unknown

William Babbington

30

Clerk

Ireland

Isabella Ballentine

28

None

Scotland

Margaret Barrett

25

None

Ireland (Cavan)

Joseph Barrett

Infant

None

Ireland

Samuel Blackburn

23

Laborer

Ireland (formerly of NY)

Samuel Blackburn, Jr.

19

Laborer

Ireland 

John Blanchard

20

Farmer

Unknown

Andrew Boyd

17

Laborer

Unknown

Bridget Brennan

17

None

Ireland

Joseph Brooks

28

Paper Maker

England (Derbyshire)

Terrance Burns

28

Laborer

Ireland

Miles Carpenter

24

None

Ireland

Margaret Carpenter

28

None

Ireland

Mary Carpenter

30

None

Unknown

Mary Carpenter

25

None

Unknown

Catharine Collins

16

None

Ireland

Mary Delaney

22

None

Ireland

Bernard Devine

20

Laborer

Ireland (Cavan)

Patrick Devine

20

Laborer

Ireland (Cavan)

Bridget Devine

20

None

Ireland (Cavan)

Margaret Dolan

18

None

Ireland 

Christopher Dolan

40

Laborer

Ireland 

Owen Durneen

30

Farmer

Ireland

Thomas Dwyer

27

Laborer

Ireland

Thomas Ellis

20

Laborer

Ireland

James Ellsworth

52

Tailor

Poughkeepsie

Martha Ellsworth

13

None

Poughkeepsie

Margaret Evans

32

None

England

George Evans

10

None

England

William Evans

9

None

England

Margaret Evans

6

None

England

John Evans

Infant

None

England

Bridget Farrell

18

None

Ireland

Catharine Galligan

25

None

Ireland (Cavan)

James Handlin

18

Laborer

Ireland

John Harden

22

Laborer

Ireland

Joseph Harford

30

Laborer

Unknown

John Hayes

30

Laborer

Ireland (Cork)

Joanna Hayes

30

None

Ireland (Cork)

Mary Hayes

4

None

Ireland (Cork)

John Hayes

Infant

None

Ireland (Cork)

Mary Higgins

50

None

Ireland

John Hope

36

Carpenter

Ireland (Dublin)

Mary Hope

32

None

Ireland (Dublin)

Wm. Hope

14

None

Ireland (Dublin)

Frederick Hope

11

None

Ireland (Dublin)

Thomas Hope

9

None

Ireland (Dublin)

Henry Hope

7

None

Ireland (Dublin)

Rose (or Rosa) Hughes

15

None

Ireland

John Jones

30

Laborer

Unknown

Wm. Jones

23

Laborer

Unknown

Charles Jones

26

Laborer

Unknown

Lewis Jones

25

Laborer

Unknown

Hannah Jones

18

None

Unknown

Bridget Kerr

22

None

Unknown

Maria Kerr

20

None

Unknown

Elizabeth Lawrence

19

None

Scotland

James Lawrence

11

None

Scotland

Catharine Lawrence

9

None

Scotland

John Leonard

25

Farmer

Ireland

Mary MacCafferty

30

None

Ireland

Sally Maguire

18

None

Unknown

Thomas Maloney

23

Laborer

Ireland

Matthew Martin

30

Steward

Ireland

Bartholw. McGlinn

40

Laborer

Ireland

Mary Metcalf

42

None

England 

Barbara Metcalf

13

None

England

Harriet Metcalf

9

None

England

Elizabeth Metcalf

7

None

England

Emanuel Metcalf

3

None

England

Thomas Mollahan

26

Laborer

Ireland                 (Rescued)

Martha Mooney

22

None

Ireland (Dublin)

Michael (or Patrick) Murray

28

Laborer

Ireland (Cavan)

Ellery Nolan

32

None

Unknown

Richard Owens

26

Farmer

Unknown            (Rescued)

William Pepper

33

Farmer

England

Judy Pepper

33

None

England

Joseph Pepper

14

None

England

William Pepper

12

None

England

Rebecca Pepper

10

None

England

David Pepper

8

None

England

Mary Ann Pepper

6

None

England

Joseph Pepper

4

None

England

John Reilly

27

Laborer

Ireland (Cavan)

Peter Rice

22

Laborer

Ireland

Wm. Robertson

35

Smith

Unknown

Catharine Ross

20

None

Ireland

Edward Smith

25

Laborer

Ireland (Cavan)

Mary Smith

25

None

Ireland (Cavan)

Elizabeth Smith

30

None

Ireland (Cork)

Robert Smith

16

None

Ireland (Cork)

William Smith

12

None

Ireland (Cork)

John Sullivan

20

Clerk

Ireland

Bridget Sullivan

18

None

Ireland

James Thompson

27

Laborer

Unknown

Sydney Thompson

27

Laborer

Unknown

David Thompson

25

Tailor

Unknown

Eleanor Tierney

18

None

Ireland (Cavan)

Elizabeth Wilson

30

None

Unknown

Thomas Wilson

7

None

Unknown

Margaret Wilson

3

None

Unknown

James Wilson

25

Laborer

Unknown

Mary Wilson

24

None

Unknown

James Wilson, infant

½

None

Unknown

John Wood

23

Weaver

Unknown             (Rescued)

John Write

28

Laborer

Unknown

Bridget Write

28

None

Unknown

Nicholas Write

2

None

Unknown

Catharine Write, infant

½

None

Unknown

 

 

 

 

111 total passengers per Liverpool Customs House Record.

21

= Average Age

 

 

 

The Crew of the Barque Mexico

Based on survivor interviews and the captain’s statements in the New York Sun, January 12, 1837.

Also the New York Commercial Advertiser, January 5, 1837; and the

U.S. National Archives Record Administration, New York City Office.

 

Names

Place of Birth

Place of Resi-dence

Citizen of

Age

Ht

 

Com

plexion

Status

Capt. Charles Winslow.

Penn-sylvania

Phila-delphia

United

States

47

5' 3"

Light

Rescued

William Broom, Supercargo

Penn-sylvania

New York

United

States

14

or 15

n/a

White

Rescued

Noah N. Jordan, First Mate

n/a

n/a

n/a

n/a

n/a

White

Fell to his death and drowned

Edward Felix, Cook

n/a

n/a

n/a

n/a

n/a

Black

Swam to Rescue Boat

John Handsell, Carpenter

n/a

n/a

n/a

n/a

n/a

White

Rescued

Stephen Simmons,

Ship’s Steward

 

n/a

n/a

n/a

n/a

n/a

Black

Frozen

SEAMEN:

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

John Francis

 

France

n/a

France

n/a

n/a

White

Rescued

Walter Quinn

 

n/a

n/a

n/a

n/a

n/a

Black

Frozen

James Munro

 

n/a

n/a

n/a

n/a

n/a

Black

Frozen

Lord Sherwood

 

n/a

n/a

n/a

n/a

n/a

Black

Frozen

Peter Pickering

 

n/a

n/a

n/a

n/a

n/a

Black

Frozen

Jacob Allen

 

n/a

n/a

n/a

n/a

n/a

Black

Frozen

 

 

 

Seven Men from Raynorstown who Conducted the Rescue of the Mexico:

 

Captain Raynor Rock Smith (51)

Zopher R. Smith (Raynor Smith’s son, 30)

James R. Smith   (Raynor Smith’s son, 28)

Oliver R. Smith   (Raynor Smith’s son, 24)

Oliver C. Smith

Samuel Raynor

Willet Smith

 

If not for Raynor Rock Smith (1785-1869), a fifty-one-year-old Long Island boat captain, fisherman, and father of eighteen children, the Mexico would have had no survivors. Smith and his six-man boat crew, including three of his sons, dragged a surfboat for several miles—one report says ten miles—from Raynorstown, across the frozen bay to where the crippled ship lay. The rescue that they accomplished through high winds, pounding surf, and slush ice is one of the most amazing feats in maritime history.

 

 

Forty-Nine Steerage Passengers Who

Drowned in the Wreck of the Bristol

(From the memory of Captain McKown.

He provided no additional information about these passengers.)

 

Sources: The New York Sun, January 12, 1837, and

The New York Herald, November 11, 1836.

 

Name

Mrs. Bennett

Mr. Braham

Wm. Buchannan

    His wife

    Their oldest child

    Their middle child

    Their youngest child

A person with last name Deary

U. Deavy

    Deavy’s sister

T. Delany

P. Diagin

    His wife

E. Dorey

Andrew Doyle

A person with last name Garshney

Pat Handerhand

T. Hundlin

A person with last name Kearney

Patrick Lamb

A person with last name Larry

Mr. Mackenott (or Macaumont or Mackeonott)

    His wife

    Their oldest daughter

    Their middle daughter

    Their youngest daughter

    Their son

Richard Markey

Rosy McDonald

A person with last name Onders

Mrs. O’Nealy

    Her daughter

    Her older son

    Her younger son

Mr. Phinegan

    His wife

Mr. Peaseley

    His wife

    Their child

Wm. Quigley

A person with last name Quinn

A person with last name Scott

A person with last name Smith

    A child with last name Smith

T. White

    His wife

    Their oldest child

    Their middle child

    Their youngest child

 

 

 

 

Nineteen Steerage Passengers Saved from the Bristol

(From the memory of Captain McKown)

 

Sources: The New York Sun, January 12, 1837;

The New York Herald, November 25, 1836;

The New York Commercial Advertiser, November 28, 1836; and

The Morning Courier, November 25, 1836.

 

 Name

Other Information

John Carr

Kildare

William Dairy

Derry, laborer

Elizabeth Dairy

Derry, first-cabin servant girl

Richard Faulkner

County Louth

John Finnigan

Dublin, wheelwright

James Gaffney

County Cavan

Patrick  Lamb

Dublin, laborer

Peter Markey

County Louth, currier

Michael McGintry 

Dublin

Patrick O’Mealy

Kings County

Thomas O’Mealy

Kings County

Michael Mooney

Kings County, laborer

Catharine Mooney

Kings County, first-cabin servant girl

John Paisley

England, butcher

John Roach

Limerick

Mr. Warren

County Wicklow

Samuel Warren

County Wicklow

James Warren

County Wicklow

Michael (no last name given)

Deaf and dumb man from Londonderry, about 40 years old

 

 

Six Passengers in Second Cabin

Who Survived the Wreck of the Bristol

 

Sources: New York Herald, November 29, 1836.

McEneny Family History. [1]

 

Name

Other Information

Michael McGintry 

(or McGinty)

None

Michael Horan

Gillen Parish in Kings County, Ireland.

Settled in Troy, New York.

   (?)Thomas, his second son

"

   (?)John, his third son

"

   (?)James, his fourth son

"

   (?)Kyran, his fifth son

"

  

 

Forty-Three Passengers in Second Cabin

Who Perished in the Wreck of the Bristol

Primarily from the recollection of Captain McKown

Sources: New York Sun, January 12, 1837.

New York Herald, November 25, 1836.

 Morning Courier & New York Express, various dates.

New York Commercial Advertiser, November 24, 1836.

 

Name

Other Information

Dr. Aiken

North of Ireland, Medical Doctor

Mrs. Andrews

Derry (She was listed as steerage in the New York Commercial Advertiser)

    Her eldest daughter 

Derry

    Her middle daughter

Derry

    Her youngest daughter

Derry

    Her son

Derry

Mr. Bailiff

Dumfries, Scotland

Thomas Black

Scotland

Mr. Burke

Tipperary

    His sister

Tipperary

Jno. Cod

Dublin

Andrew Doyle

Donoghue, Ireland

John Dunn

Dublin, Shoemaker

D. Evans

None

Mr. Stephen Graham

Manchester, England 

    His nephew, initials “N.T.”

None

S. Graham

Tailor

Mr. Graham

Lived in America for sixteen years. Went back to England to bring his nephew over.

    His nephew, Thomas G. Graham

England

T. Horton

None

Mr. Lacey

None

Mrs. Lacey

None

Mrs. Lucy

Dublin

Mr. McDermott

Donoghue, Ireland

A person with the last name McFacters

None

Dr. McMullin

North of Ireland, Medical Doctor

A person with the last name O’Reilly

Dublin

A person with the last name Reilly (or Reily)

None

Christopher Shields

Brooklyn (died on shore)

J. Thomas

None

Lewis Thomas

Wales

Thomas Thomas

Wales

Mr. Warren

None

    His elder son

None

    His younger son

None

James Will

Scotland

Mr. Wise

None

    His cousin, Georgia Wise

None

Mrs. Wolfe

England

    Her niece

England

Unidentified woman

New York, Dressmaker

Unidentified woman

New York

Unidentified man

None

 

 

 

Ten Passengers in First Cabin on the Bristol

(A list from the memory of Captain McKown)

(See the Steerage List for the four others who were in the round-house)

Sources:

New York Sun, January 12, 1837.

LI Democrat, December 7, 1836.

 

Name

Other Information

Survival

Mrs. Frances Hogan (65)

Widow of Michael Hogan, Esq., of New York City, the U.S. consul at Valparaiso, Chile.

Survived the wreck.

Miss Frances (“Fanny”) Hogan (41)

Daughter of Mrs. Hogan, resident of New York City

Survived the wreck.

Mrs. Sophia Donnelly (34)

Daughter of Mrs. Hogan, traveling from India to NYC via England with her husband and two children.

Survived the wreck.

Mr. Arthur Donnelly

Husband of Sophia Donnelly, an English merchant of Irish descent, emigrating to NYC with his family.

Escaped from the cabin, but drowned later.

The Donnellys’ elder daughter, a child

Born in Calcutta, India.

Survived the wreck.

The Donnellys’ younger daughter, a child

Born in Calcutta, India.

Survived the wreck.

Vinissa, nursemaid to the Donnellys’ children

Of New York City. Previously Mrs. Hogan’s slave in Cape Town, Africa. Freed in 1804 and indentured to the Hogans until 1828.

Survived the wreck.

Francis Burtsall, Esq.

None

Survived the wreck.

 

James Hale Carleton

Originally from Bristol, England.

Escaped from the cabin, but drowned later.

Edward Ash Carleton

 

Originally from Bristol, England.

Escaped from the cabin, but drowned later.

 

 

Thirty-two of the Bristol’s passengers and twelve crewmen, including the captain, were saved on the stormy day and night of November 21, 1836. Ninety-five passengers and five crewmen drowned. Surely, any list of the bravest men in maritime history must include those who risked their lives for others that day:

 

Alexander McKown, Captain

Arthur Donnelly, Passenger

 

The rescuers from Rockaway:

David T. Jennings, Wreck-Master

John Abrams, Boatman

Hiram Abrams, Boatman

George Combs, Boatman

Thomas Combs, Boatman

Oliver Cornell, Boatman

Oliver Cornell, Boatman

Gilbert Craft, Boatman

 

 

 



[1] The details of the McEneny Family History are imprecise as to specifically which of Michael Horan’s children traveled with him on the Bristol.